Frugal snacks; popcorn and choosing a brand

Hot air popcorn

Popcorn is a frugal snack and doesn’t take much effort if you have a hot air popper. We have been buying Walmart’s Great Value Yellow Popcorn for $1.66 in-store. For that price we get at least 16 servings, or about 10 cents a serving plus the cost of butter so let’s say 25 cents a serving max. Much cheaper than buying it pre-made, or buying potato chips. We were enjoying it until Walmart was out of Great Value and instead we bought Jolly Time Pop Corn White for $1.94 in store.  The Jolly time was way better, much softer when cooked in the hot air popper. This got me thinking, how many brands do we use, where we are happy with it, but a much better option exists? How would we know?

Popcorn forensics

I’m a big fan of doing research before buying almost anything. Why not get the best value? We buy a lot of our goods online from Amazon where we have instant access to many reviews. I can find out quickly what the best rated product in a category is, and I usually read enough reviews to understand what the strengths and weaknesses of a product are. But what about groceries? DW shops in-store, so the reviews aren’t in view when buying. We have brands we have used for years. But what if there is a product we would enjoy much more, even if it costs a bit more? So I looked at Walmart’s rating for the popcorn after the fact.

Walmart ratings

For the Great Value Yellow Popcorn there were 90 reviews on the Walmart site as of 1-15-2018. The rating was 4.0. For the Jolly Time there were 40 ratings and the average was 4.2. Pretty close. But the ratio of 4 stars to 5 stars was different. For Great Value the ratio was 51/15 = 3.4. For Jiffy it was 26/5 = 5.2. I am not saying this is scientific, but in the future I am going to look at this ratio.

Final thoughts

DW and I both greatly prefer the Jolly time when popped in our hot air popper. This makes me wonder how many other grocery items we buy regularly, where there is a different brand we would greatly prefer. I will be comparing some brands we use a lot to see, stay tuned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *